By Morse Building Consultancy | Updated November 2026
Independent building assessments and evidence-based reporting for insurance claims, property damage, defects and disputes.
Morse Building Consultancy (MBC) provides independent building consultancy services across Australia, helping insurers, loss adjusters, brokers, strata managers, legal professionals and property owners understand building damage and make informed decisions.
Our licensed building consultants investigate causation, assess damage and building condition, identify defects and compliance issues, and prepare factual technical reports.
Our approach is straightforward. We follow the evidence, not a predetermined outcome.
Request a Building Consultancy Assessment
Independent building consultancy provides technical assessment of building damage, defects, causation and rectification requirements, separate from the contractor undertaking repairs.
Causation matters. A building can have genuine event-related damage alongside pre-existing deterioration, maintenance issues or defective workmanship. Each needs to be considered.
Evidence comes first. MBC assesses physical observations, building history, documentation and relevant technical information before reaching conclusions.
Reporting should explain the findings. A useful report identifies what was observed, the evidence supporting the opinion, any limitations and what further action may be required.
National expertise. MBC operates across all Australian states and territories and has assessed more than 6,000 matters. Founder Andrew Morse brings more than 38 years of building and construction experience.
A building consultant investigates building condition, damage, defects and construction issues to establish the likely cause, extent and appropriate rectification. The consultant provides technical findings that can support insurance claims, repairs, dispute resolution and property decisions.
MBC's building consultants investigate damage caused by storms, hail, cyclones, flooding, fire, vehicle impact and water ingress. They also assess deterioration, defective workmanship, maintenance-related conditions and other construction issues.
An important part of this work is distinguishing damage associated with a reported event from conditions that may have existed beforehand.
Our assessments draw on practical building knowledge, physical evidence and, where applicable, the National Construction Code (NCC) and relevant Australian Standards.
A building consultant does not determine whether an insurance policy covers the damage. Their role is to provide technical evidence that the insurer and other stakeholders can consider when making decisions.
An independent building consultant should be considered when the cause, extent or appropriate repair of building damage is uncertain, complex or disputed.
Common reasons include:
Storm, flood, fire, impact or water damage requiring independent causation assessment.
Conflicting contractor reports, technical opinions or repair quotations.
Insurance claims involving possible pre-existing damage, deterioration or construction defects.
Repair scopes that do not adequately explain the proposed works or their relationship to the identified damage.
Suspected defective workmanship, non-compliant construction or recurring maintenance problems.
Disputes between insurers, property owners, builders or strata committees.
Building damage requiring further investigation or assessment by a registered engineer.
Engaging the appropriate consultant early can help establish what evidence is needed and reduce uncertainty before repairs are planned or a claim becomes more complicated.
Independence means the findings must reflect the evidence, regardless of who commissions the report.
MBC does not undertake building repairs as part of its independent assessment service. Our consultants investigate the circumstances, document the evidence and form a technical opinion without a commercial interest in securing the associated repair work.
As founder and Managing Director Andrew Morse explains:
"We follow the evidence, not the desired outcome."
A report may identify damage caused by the reported event. It may also identify longstanding defects, deterioration, inadequate maintenance or earlier damage. Sometimes several factors have contributed.
The consultant's responsibility is to explain those findings accurately, including any uncertainty.
This approach is particularly important in complex insurance matters, where a technical opinion may be reviewed by an insurer, policyholder, broker, another expert or a dispute resolution body.
Learn more about Andrew Morse's approach to independent building investigations.
Morse Building Consultancy provides nine core service areas, combining practical building experience with engineering, investigative, reporting and cost assessment expertise.
Service | What it covers | Typical clients |
|---|---|---|
Building Consultancy | Damage causation, defects, compliance and rectification advice | Insurers, brokers, property owners, strata |
Reporting & Scope of Works | Technical reports, repair methodologies and itemised scopes | Insurers, loss adjusters, legal teams |
Damage Reporting & Disaster Assessment | Post-event damage assessment and catastrophe response | Insurers, brokers, loss adjusters |
Quantity Surveying & Cost Assessments | Insurance valuations, construction costing and cost reviews | Insurers, brokers, property stakeholders |
Construction Dispute Resolution | Independent assessments of workmanship, defects and construction disputes | Insurers, lawyers, builders, owners |
Site Investigations | Investigation of water ingress, structural concerns and building failures | Insurers, strata, property managers |
Structural Investigations | Structural damage, movement, deterioration and failure analysis | Insurers, loss adjusters, owners |
Expert Witness | Independent technical reports and evidence for legal proceedings | Lawyers, insurers, private clients |
Project Management | Client-side oversight of repair, rectification and rebuild projects | Insurers, strata, commercial owners |
MBC's building consultancy services cover the investigation of building damage, construction defects, workmanship and compliance issues.
Our consultants consider how a building was constructed, how its materials and systems have performed over time, and whether the available evidence supports the reported cause of damage.
For matters involving multiple possible causes, an independent assessment can distinguish event-related damage from conditions requiring separate maintenance or rectification.
Our building and structural consultancy services provide further information about how our consultants and engineers support complex property matters.
A building report documents the consultant's technical findings. A scope of works identifies the repairs or rectification recommended in response to those findings.
MBC prepares reports addressing building condition, damage causation, defects and relevant compliance considerations. Where requested, we also develop detailed repair scopes identifying the work required, materials, quantities and applicable technical requirements.
The level of detail depends on the property and complexity of the matter.
A repair scope should follow the evidence established during the investigation. It should not include work that has no clear technical basis without separately identifying why that work is proposed.
Read more about MBC's building reports and scopes of works.
Damage reporting documents the nature, location and extent of building damage following an event such as a storm, flood, fire, cyclone or impact.
MBC assists with single-property investigations and larger catastrophe events, providing independent assessments to help insurers and other stakeholders understand the damage and determine the next steps.
Our disaster assessment and damage reporting services include site investigations, causation assessment and repair reporting following significant property events.
MBC provides independent quantity surveying, construction cost assessments and property valuation services.
These include Value at Risk (VAR) assessments, indemnity valuations, repair cost reviews, tender assessments and variation analysis.
A VAR assessment considers the estimated replacement or reinstatement cost of an asset for insurance purposes. An indemnity valuation considers reinstatement to a condition equivalent to that immediately before the loss, with appropriate allowances for factors such as age, condition and depreciation.
The valuation basis and scope depend on the purpose of the assessment and the client's instructions.
Our quantity surveying and insurance cost assessment services support insurers, brokers and property stakeholders requiring independent financial and construction cost information.
Construction disputes often involve disagreement about workmanship, compliance, damage causation or the extent of required rectification.
MBC provides independent technical investigations and reports that help identify the issues in dispute and establish the evidence relevant to each.
Our findings may assist negotiations, mediation, formal dispute resolution or legal proceedings.
Learn more about our construction dispute resolution services.
A site investigation is a targeted assessment to establish the cause or contributing factors behind a building problem.
MBC investigates water ingress, deterioration, structural concerns, building envelope failures and suspected construction defects.
Depending on the circumstances, an investigation may involve site measurements, moisture testing, photographic evidence, construction documentation, material examination or input from other specialists.
Our site investigation services help establish what is occurring before repairs or other actions are recommended.
Structural investigations examine problems that may affect the stability, performance or integrity of a building or its components.
These can include cracking, foundation movement, subsidence, roof structure damage, concrete deterioration, corrosion or failure of structural elements.
Where structural adequacy, engineered repairs or certification are required, the assessment may involve a registered structural engineer.
MBC's structural investigation services provide independent technical assessment for residential, commercial, industrial and strata properties.
MBC provides expert witness services for building and construction matters involving defects, workmanship, damage causation, compliance and disputes.
Our consultants and engineers prepare technical opinions within their areas of expertise, with expert witness reporting and testimony undertaken in accordance with the requirements relevant to the proceedings.
MBC provides client-side project management for repair, rectification and reinstatement projects, including complex insurance-related works.
Our role may include reviewing repair requirements, coordinating contractors, monitoring progress, assessing variations and overseeing compliance with the agreed scope.
This service supports insurers, strata organisations and commercial property stakeholders managing significant building works.
Building damage can have several possible causes. A reliable causation assessment examines those possibilities against the available evidence rather than accepting an explanation solely because damage became visible after a particular event.
MBC's assessment process considers the building, its history, the reported event and the technical questions requiring investigation.
The investigation begins with the available site evidence.
This may include photographs, measurements, damage patterns, material condition, previous repairs, maintenance records, construction documentation and earlier reports.
The consultant considers how the affected components were constructed, how they have performed and whether the observed conditions are consistent with the reported cause.
Visible damage does not necessarily establish when or why it occurred.
For example, a roof may contain recent hail impacts alongside earlier indentations, corrosion or previous repairs. Water ingress may be associated with a storm, a longstanding waterproofing defect or several contributing conditions.
The consultant investigates the relevant evidence to determine which explanations are supported and which require further examination.
Where relevant, MBC considers information from the Bureau of Meteorology alongside the physical evidence.
Weather records, radar imagery and storm warnings can help establish the conditions experienced in an area. However, they do not independently prove that a particular building was damaged during that event.
An assessment may also involve moisture mapping, material testing, thermal imaging, level measurements or other investigative methods where appropriate.
MBC explores this distinction in greater detail in Can weather data prove hail damage? Why site evidence still matters in insurance claims.
Building condition and proposed rectification may require consideration of the National Construction Code, applicable legislation and relevant Australian Standards.
This requires care with older properties.
A building constructed decades ago may have complied with the requirements in place at the time, even though those requirements differ from current standards. Proposed repair work may introduce new compliance obligations depending on the nature of the work and the relevant jurisdiction.
The Australian Building Codes Board publishes the NCC, but adoption dates, transitional arrangements and state or territory variations must also be considered.
The report records the relevant observations and explains the technical reasoning supporting the consultant's conclusions.
It should distinguish established facts from interpretations, acknowledge contributing factors and identify any limitations in the available evidence.
Where a definitive cause cannot be established, further investigation may be recommended.
The objective is to provide a clear, factual technical opinion that stakeholders can understand and consider.
An independent building consultant assesses the physical characteristics of the damage, building history and available event information to determine which conditions are consistent with recent damage and which may have developed over time.
For example, the condition of roof coatings, corrosion, previous patching, impact patterns and surrounding building elements may help establish whether particular damage is recent or historical.
The assessment should also consider whether the reported event caused new damage to an element that already had an existing defect.
These distinctions are not always straightforward.
An older roof may have genuine recent hail damage and longstanding corrosion. An existing waterproofing defect may contribute to water ingress during a storm. Damage becoming visible after severe weather does not necessarily mean every affected component was damaged by that event.
A reliable report explains the evidence supporting each finding rather than treating all damage as having one cause.
A useful building report explains what was investigated, what evidence was considered and why the consultant reached their conclusions.
For insurers and claims professionals, that means the report should address the questions relevant to the claim, rather than simply provide observations without sufficient explanation.
Depending on the matter, a report may include:
The instructions and purpose of the assessment.
Property information and relevant history.
Site observations, photographs and measurements.
Testing results and documentation reviewed.
Causation findings and contributing factors.
The extent of event-related and pre-existing conditions.
Relevant building standards and compliance considerations.
Technical assumptions, limitations and areas requiring further investigation.
Recommendations for repairs, rectification or specialist assessment.
The Insurance Council of Australia's guidance on expert reports also emphasises relevant expertise, factual and neutral reporting, supporting evidence and clear explanations of technical opinions.
A report's length alone is not a measure of quality.
A straightforward matter may require a relatively concise report. A major loss involving several buildings, disputed causation or significant structural concerns may require substantially more investigation and documentation.
Andrew Morse discusses the importance of thorough investigation and reporting in The Devil is in the Detail.
Independent building consultancy provides technical information that brokers, claims managers and loss adjusters can use when property damage is complex or disputed.
This is particularly valuable when an initial report does not fully explain the damage, competing opinions have emerged or the proposed repair scope requires further clarification.
An independent assessment may help establish:
The likely cause and extent of damage.
Whether pre-existing conditions contributed to the loss.
Whether further specialist investigation is required.
The technical basis for recommended repairs.
Whether the scope of works addresses the identified damage.
What uncertainties remain before the claim can progress.
For insurance brokers, this information can assist discussions with insurers when their clients are concerned about a claim assessment or repair proposal.
A broker may request that an insurer consider appointing an independent building consultant, particularly where further technical clarification is required.
For insurers and loss adjusters, well-supported findings can help reduce supplementary enquiries, repeated investigations and uncertainty surrounding repair decisions.
MBC provides the technical evidence. The insurer remains responsible for determining the policy response and claim outcome.
MBC combines practical construction knowledge, insurance-specific reporting experience and national building and engineering expertise.
Established experience
Founded in 2012, MBC has assessed more than 6,000 matters. Founder and Managing Director Andrew Morse has more than 38 years of building industry experience and has personally investigated and reported on more than 2,400 matters.
Independent technical reporting
Our consultants assess the available evidence without a predetermined conclusion or commercial interest in carrying out the repair work.
Building and engineering expertise
Our national network includes licensed building consultants and registered engineers with experience in construction, building damage, defects and structural investigations.
Insurance industry knowledge
MBC's services are developed around the technical information required by insurers, loss adjusters, brokers and claims professionals.
Professional involvement
MBC is a Corporate Founding Member of the Association of Insurance Building and Engineering Consultants (AiBEC). Andrew Morse has also participated in initiatives supporting professional standards in expert reporting.
National service capability
MBC operates across Queensland, New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia, Western Australia, Tasmania, the Northern Territory and the Australian Capital Territory, with assignments coordinated according to the expertise and availability required.
Read more about Andrew Morse and his building consultancy experience.
Yes. An independent building consultant can review an existing report, assess its findings against the available evidence and investigate technical questions that remain unresolved.
The review may identify areas requiring further clarification, additional evidence or another site inspection.
Its purpose is to establish an independent technical opinion, not simply to disagree with an earlier assessment.
A building report investigates technical matters such as damage, causation, building condition and rectification requirements.
A repair quotation generally provides a price for undertaking specified work.
A contractor may provide useful observations, but a quotation does not necessarily establish the cause of damage or provide the technical evidence required for a complex insurance decision.
No. A building consultant does not accept, reject or determine insurance coverage.
The consultant provides technical findings about matters such as causation, damage extent, pre-existing conditions and recommended repairs.
The insurer considers those findings alongside the applicable policy terms, exclusions and conditions when making its claim decision.
A building consultant generally investigates building condition, defects, causation, workmanship and practical rectification.
A structural engineer assesses structural adequacy, stability, loads, material performance and engineered repair requirements.
Where structural design, certification or other regulated engineering work is required, an appropriately registered engineer may need to undertake that work.
Some investigations benefit from both disciplines.
A building consultant may be able to distinguish recent damage from historical conditions by examining physical characteristics, weathering, corrosion, previous repairs, property records and available event information.
The certainty of any conclusion depends on the quality and availability of the evidence.
Not by itself.
Meteorological information can establish that severe weather occurred in an area, but the building's physical condition must also be investigated to assess whether the reported damage is consistent with that event.
MBC explains this in its guide to hail damage causation and weather evidence.
Not automatically.
The applicable requirements depend on when the building was constructed, the nature of any proposed work and the legislation applying in the relevant jurisdiction.
An existing building may have complied with its original requirements while proposed repairs or alterations trigger additional obligations.
The timeframe depends on the location, complexity of the matter, access requirements, testing and reporting scope.
Some matters require a single inspection, while complex investigations may need several visits or input from registered engineers and other specialists.
MBC can advise on the likely requirements and timing once the instructions have been reviewed.
Yes. An independent building report may provide technical evidence relevant to internal dispute resolution, an Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) complaint, negotiation or legal proceedings.
The report's usefulness depends on the issues in dispute, the expertise of the consultant and the quality and relevance of the evidence.
A report prepared specifically for court or tribunal proceedings may need to meet additional expert evidence requirements.
Yes. MBC operates nationally, including regional and remote areas.
The availability and timing of a particular assessment depend on the location, required expertise, travel arrangements and current consultant capacity.
A Value at Risk assessment estimates replacement or reinstatement cost for insurance purposes, based on the relevant property characteristics and valuation assumptions.
An indemnity valuation generally considers the cost of restoring an asset to a condition equivalent to its pre-loss state, with relevant adjustments for age, condition and depreciation.
The appropriate valuation method depends on the purpose and instructions of the assessment.
Learn more about MBC's quantity surveying and valuation services.
Morse Building Consultancy assists insurers, brokers, loss adjusters, legal professionals and property stakeholders requiring independent technical assessments.
If you're dealing with complex property damage, uncertain causation, building defects or disputed repairs, our team can discuss the matter and the appropriate expertise required.
Contact Morse Building Consultancy to request an assessment.
Phone: 1300 066 773